Al-An‘āmالأنعام 6:141
Choose authorities (8 selected)
Same choice as Abrogation claims by authority.
Abrogation claimed: 4 authorities
| Authority | Abrogated by | Type | Verdict | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abu Ja'far al-Nahhas | آية الزكاة | ruling only | claim reported | p. 2/322 |
| Makki b. Abi Talib al-Qaysi | آية الزكاة | ruling only | claim reported | p. 283 |
| Abu Bakr Ibn al-'Arabi | آية الزكاة | ruling only | claim reported | p. 2/217 |
| Abu al-Faraj Ibn al-Jawzi | آية الزكاة | ruling only | claim reported | p. 2/431 |
"claim reported" = the authority discusses the claim; no reader has yet confirmed his verdict. · all claims by verse
Commentary on the readings (Qālūn)
This verse was read by ‘Alī Ibn Abī Tālib as “It is he who produces gardens planted
and unplanted”.
The word used in the current Arabic Qur’ān, ma‘rūshāt (“with trailed...vines”),
comes from the verb ‘arasha (“to build a wooden structure”). When one says
i‘tarasha al-‘arish, the meaning is “the vines have climbed the trellises.” The gardens
that are ma‘rūshāt in the verse are the vineyards. As to the planted ones, maghrūsāt from the verb gharasa, it means to plant in the ground. This is a difference in the technical imaging of the verse.
If the reading had come from one source, we would not have found this difference.
One reading highlights the vines on the trellises, and another refers to the plants planted in the ground.
قرأها علي بن أبي طالب: «وَهُوَ الَّذِي أَنشَأَ جَنَّاتٍ مَغْرُوسَاتٍ وَغَيْرَ مَغْرُوسَاتٍ».
الـ <مَعْرَوشات> من فعل «عَرَشَ»: أي بنى بناءً من خشب. ويقال اعترش العريش، إذا ارتفع على العِراش. والجنات المَعْروشَات في الآية هي الكروم. أما الـ «مَغْروسَات»، من فعل غَرس الشّجر في الأرض. وهذا فرق في التصوير الفني للآية. ولو كانت القراءة من مصدر واحد لما وجدنا هذا الفرق: فقراءة تسلط الأضواء على المعروش وأخرى تشير إلى المغروس.
References: الخطيب 2: 568.